Beckwith Grove Bridge over Kananook Creek

[Noel Tudball]

• March, 2021: Yes, it’s on the table again – this time, to sell the land/pathway from Kananook Creek to Beckwith Grove, which would mean the bridge would never be built - more http://www.seafordcc.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=193&p=876#p876.
  
• 25 September 2017: Not to be replaced - Council Decision = Resolves not to reconstruct the bridge - more: http://www.seafordcc.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=193&p=682#p682
  

http://www.frankston.vic.gov.au/Your_Council/Media_and_Publications/Latest_News/Notification_of_Works

Current at December 18, 2015:

• Kananook Creek Pedestrian Bridge
  - Works Commencing: 2016
  - Location: Beckwith Grove, Seaford
  - Duration of Works: To be advised

[Noel Tudball]

Feedback closes March 18.

The case of the missing bridge .......... solved!

At our stall at the February Seaford Farmers' Market, a resident alerted us to the fact that the pedestrian bridge over Kananook Creek at Beckwith Grove (via Brodie St) had disappeared.

An alert member spotted this post on FCC's Facebook page on 4th March, 2016:

Have your say online about the future of the pedestrian bridge over Kananook Creek at Beckwith Grove in Seaford.

This bridge was recently demolished due to safety. Council is undertaking consultation to gauge the community’s interest in replacing the bridge, as some residents have indicated they would prefer that the bridge was not replaced.

Complete a short online feedback form, here - http://www.frankston.vic.gov.au/Your_Council/Have_Your_Say/Beckwith_Grove_Pedestrian_Bridge_Seaford/Comment_on_the_Beckwith_Grove_Pedestrian_Bridge


Click here to see where the bridge was - Google Maps

(Click on image to view & close)

Beckwith Grove.jpg (38.77 KiB) Viewed 7128 times

[Noel Tudball]

We received advice in April 2016 that this bridge would be replaced "like for like, aesthetically" (apologies for not updating this Topic at that time).
However, it seems the work order was overlooked and the funds were reallocated - it can happen.

At the 18th July FCC meeting, a local residents' petition of 331 (?) signatures was tabled, requesting its replacement.

There were apologies all 'round and Councillors voted unanimously to reinstate the work order and have the bridge replaced ASAP.

[Noel Tudball]

A recent article on the bridge.

Beckwith Grove Bridge.jpg (137.18 KiB) Viewed 6773 times

Source: http://www.heraldsun.com.au/leader/south-east/frankston-council-to-rebuild-pedestrian-bridge-at-seaford-after-copping-backlash-from-residents/news-story/79d2c79273082c11403e811a2a5a6aa0

Frankston Council to rebuild pedestrian.pdf

The full artcile

(708.88 KiB) Downloaded 346 times

[Noel Tudball]

And on the agenda for FCC meeting - 3 July 2017:

http://www.frankston.vic.gov.au/Your_Council/Council_and_Committee_Meetings/Council_Agendas_and_Minutes_2017

[Noel Tudball]

And again - 25 September 2017:

Detailed information regarding quotations is in the Agenda - http://www.frankston.vic.gov.au/Your_Council/Council_and_Committee_Meetings/Council_Agendas_and_Minutes_2017
News Article - http://baysidenews.com.au/2017/10/09/bridge-troubled-water-binned/
News Article - http://www.heraldsun.com.au/leader/south-east/frankston-council-backs-out-on-pledge-to-rebuild-historic-seaford-bridge/news-story/2c76bec8f7aaf4bfb3f02cfbb5ae8828

I understand that the bridge can be built without disability provisions but it would mean that the bridge would not be insured.
Portions of properties either side of the narrow laneway also needed to be acquired.

With regard to point 5. in the Motion below, some have said that it appears that insufficient research into disability access was undertaken when the first cost estimates were made.

Council Decision - that Council:
3. Resolves not to reconstruct the bridge.
1. Receives an external report at Attachment A outlining a comparison of alternative materials that could be considered for the construction of Beckwith Grove Bridge.
2. Notes receipt of legal advice which outlines Council’s legal obligations and the completion of an Access Audit and recommendations which enables Council to resolve to build the bridge with either with disability access or without disability access based on ‘justifiable hardship’.
4. Writes to all residents within immediate proximity to the former Beckwith Bridge explaining Council’s recent decision. The letter is to explain why the Council has overturned the previous decision of Council on this matter – i.e. modern disability access requirements, escalating construction costs etc.
5. Instructs the CEO to install a checks-and-balances process to prevent the expenditure of public monies on conceptual designs that do not take into account the full scope of required works (ie. disability access, public safety,
statutory specifications etc). Upon the implementation of this new checks-and-balances process, the new procedure is to be articulated in a report to Council in January 2018.
Carried Unanimously

[Noel Tudball]

*****
UPDATE: DEFERRED: the item on the FCC meeting agenda to discuss the bridge was deferred.
*****

Yes, after 4 years, it’s on the table again – this time, to sell the land/pathway from Kananook Creek to Beckwith Grove, which would mean the bridge would never be built.

Those who feel strongly about the bridge might like to register to address the FCC meeting on Monday 1 March 2021.

Refer to the agenda items (see images and links below) for items that speakers might raise.

Some have already raised with me:

• The topic should be deferred until community discussion is held
• Where did this 1 March meeting come from? It is not listed in the document: “Council Meeting Dates 2021”
• Does the timing of this unannounced/unplanned meeting/agenda item have anything to do with the KCA Botanic Garden (formerly Arboretum) Plan currently being discussed again? (The Garden had planned to use the bridge in the Plan)
• Is this unannounced/unplanned meeting/agenda item in line with Agenda item: 12.3 “Adoption of Community Engagement Policy” that is also on the agenda for this meeting?

Agenda: https://www.frankston.vic.gov.au/Your_Council/Council_and_Committee_Meetings/Council_Agendas_and_Minutes_2021

If you are interested in speaking at the meeting, it is via phone only because the meeting will not be open to the public and will only be via online live streaming due to the pandemic. (A link to the streaming source is on the same page as the agenda.)

Register to speak at FCC meeting: https://www.frankston.vic.gov.au/Your_Council/Council_and_Committee_Meetings/Council_Meetings/Request_to_Speak_at_a_Council_Meeting, also accessible via the agenda link.

FCC Beckwith Bridge 1 March 2021 Agenda.pdf

FCC Beckwith Bridge 1 March 2021 Agenda (6MB)

(5.95 MiB) Downloaded 11 times

FCC Beckwith Bridge 1 March 2021 Agenda

FCC Beckwith Bridge 1 March 2021 Agenda 2.jpg (91.36 KiB) Viewed 455 times

FCC Beckwith Bridge 1 March 2021 Agenda

Beckwith Grove Bridge 1 March FCC meeting 1.png (101.96 KiB) Viewed 455 times